Hey Jeff! So I'm going to address your statement to me in question #3 as, like you said, it's intertwined, so I'll answer it all together.
1. A lot was made in this game and then amongst the jury in Ponderosa about pre-game alliances, connections, and relationships. I'd like you to be honest here and talk about the relationships and connections you had coming in. What were they? How did they benefit you? and how much of an advantage do you feel you had in this game by having them?
So I'll run through the jury and fellow finalists and give my two cents on the extent of the relationships I had with them coming into the game.
Cristina: We maybe played together like twice, years back? In Bloo's World. But we weren't close, and had a much better relationship here. Legit I don't think we even talked about it because it seemed pointless, so maybe she doesn't even remember.
Melinda: I think we just played once, where we made it to the end together and she won. Probably like a me and Yve type relationship where we never met until the merge and didn't vote the same way the whole way through, rather than being especially in-sync allies.
Tammy: We've crossed paths a few times before in Catalie's games but honestly we've never had the chance to be close allies or anything, and I'm sure she would agree.
Catalie: I've played many of her games and played with her many times, including making the end with her once like a year and a half ago. Some experiences were good and others not so much.
Kim: Off the top of my head we've played together maybe like three times? I don't think we were especially close in the others and we both saw this as the closest we've been.
Russell: I think we played together once ever before this? A game where I was second boot, if that even counts. I have played for him before, including his game which finished when this one started.
I mean, no offence to any of those people but I'm sure they'd agree we didn't exactly have a close friendship coming into this that'd define our in-game relationship, nor was it some shoe-in alliance because I played game X with them five years ago where we weren't even close and maybe interacted for like three rounds. Catalie and I were close by virtue of us spending the entire pre-merge together and our journey through NuFenrir and losing Val first up at the merge, that type of thing would make any two people into a duo.
I'd say for Catalie and I knowing our past experiences did help us together in that we knew we generally worked well together from the same side, and I know she's a fantastic ally to those she pledges her allegiance to and is a strategic and social force, so I knew from our past that teaming up with Catalie from day one would be advantageous. I can't speak for Russell but maybe him seeing me play his series made him inclined to work with me if he likes my style. I kind of doubt it but really not sure, we didn't even trust each other for chunks of this game honestly. Again, this was the first time I've properly played with him so I didn't really know what to expect with him. And Melinda, well it didn't hurt the one time we'd played together we made the end, so I think we both knew that success was in the cards if we teamed up, which is arguably something we used to our advantage.
You, Val, Penner, Loveita, Joaquin, Cassandra and Yve I've never played with or spoken to in any capacity before this, to my best knowledge, but as I answered in my response to Joaquin, Loveita and Val were two of my closest friends and allies in this throughout and I stayed loyal to them and voted alongside them the nights they were eliminated, so I was never set on aligning those I knew ahead of those I didn't, loved meeting new people and was very open to playing with anyone who was wanting to play with me.
Did these past relationships hurt me? No, there was never any bad blood to the point where I felt someone would specifically gun for me as payback for a past game. It doesn't hurt to see a familiar face you have some experience with, so if that can be seen as an advantage, sure. I'm not going to pretend that past relationships aren't a factor, past games aren't talked about because that's the case in any Open ID game. I was certainly trying to keep track of people who'd played multiple Stranded seasons together and whatnot, because in terms of this series the only "connection" (which wasn't even a positive or negative one, we barely met in Namibia) I had was with Cochran and we never even got to play together here and some of the others have played a bunch of seasons together. So I'd be guilty of trying to piece together who knows who as well because obviously these are things to come into mind, but at the end of the day I expected people to play for their own best interests above all and take this game at face value, which was my approach too.
2. I get bored very easily so something I value in this game is when someone can play well while also being entertaining/funny. Please talk about a particular moment in this game where you were at your most entertaining. If you can't come up with a moment where you were entertaining in a public setting, please feel free to talk about a moment/story where you were entertaining otherwise.
Well, I'd rather bring it back to you because obviously we didn't have a
ton of time together, a mere two rounds but I did thoroughly enjoy our social connection for what it was worth, even though we unfortunately weren't able to develop a strategic one. I do think our "ice breaker" game to impersonate each of the pre-jurors we knew, who the other hadn't met (Courtney, Kim Spradlin, Mookie for you, and then Penny and Ziggy for me, and I think Cochran too even though I "knew" him from Namibia).
In a lot of ways it was super dumb and silly but that's the way I like it, and I think lightened the mood for us and broke the ice. And then you went and did the challenge right after and said you crushed it and I deserved "half-credit" and I told you I deserved full credit because my impressions were
obviously spot on and helped you.
And then I said if you win you should give me the necklace for my efforts and I said it looks better on you anyway (trying to do a Penny and flirt with you!) and you were like "W t f please tell me you don't
actually find Varner attractive?!?!" and I promised you I didn't, lol, and was just teasing. And then you did win the challenge! And as you knew you were likely getting the votes that went Yve's way that round, so I saw the humor in the situation all around and hoped you did too.
So seeing as you get bored easily I hope I entertained you and you had fun with that conversation because you did me! It was a fun little game to play to get us comfortable and open up to each other and made me feel that had we'd been faced with a different dynamic we could've developed that social relationship even further and possibly develop a strategic one. Unfortunately it just wasn't meant to be.
In terms of other moments I was funny in public, well when I said *whispers to poody's client* when he asked us to not talk to them (Sapphire Elevator) during the whisperfest when Val got booted, that got a bunch of likes from the other players, hosts and viewers so I'd like to think they thought that was funny because I was trying to be humorous!
3. There wasn't enough JEFF when I CTRL+F'd "JEFF" in your opening statements so I want that to change by asking a totally Jeff-centric question. Please talk about the first two merge rounds and why the target was so squarely on me, your role on it being there (if applicable), and how it affected (positively or negatively) your game for me to be voted out.
So as I said, I'm addressing both your statement to me and this question in one fell swoop because it ties in together. I already addressed this in question two, but I really did feel great about our conversations and enjoyed them thoroughly, a genuine friendship was quickly forming between us and I had no doubts we would've hit it off had we had pre-merge time together, because we already were making up ground and trying to see if we could bridge our games together despite contrasting allegiances.
When you came to me about protecting each other the first few rounds of the merge and then develop that into something stronger as we head deep into the merge, I really wanted that for us. Unfortunately, there were a few things which weren't working in your favor which weren't even necessarily in your control or anything you did wrong.
Firstly, your swap tribe was the only one which had any real drama/dissension that appeared to be coming into the merge, and the rest of us were all made well aware of Joaquin's idol play and Tammy voting with him and Russell, against you, Cochran and Yve. On the other hand, Catalie, Val and I were obviously a trio who had worked together to eliminate Alex, Aubry and Courtney, and the six NuMunin hadn't had to test their waters seeing as they never went to Tribal Council, so they were able to keep up the pretence of being unified for at least the time being as no lines had officially been drawn.
The merge dynamic was never going to be straightforward with all the interwoven connections, and obviously fourteen is a monumental step up from the smaller tribes we were just experiencing, but unfortunately, I think Jormungand got the focus put on them where it was already seen as a divided tribe, so the impression I got was people saw the value in taking advantage of that while the dust settles and a more clear dynamic develops.
The other thing working against you was the Munin/Fenrir divide, which was 8-6 in favor of Munin. These tribal lines were never going to hold up forever, and obviously I voted out a bunch of Munin before Fenrir, flipped to the three Fenrir at final seven against the three Munin, to vote off Joaquin. But sure, as soon as we merged, obviously amongst all the Munin there were discussions of the eight of us sticking together for the first couple of votes. I felt pretty good about most people within the tribe given my ranking in round three so didn't really feel a specific urge to flip or take out any of them without any indication they were planning the same to me.
Tammy was obviously a no-go as an option seeing as she'd flipped to vote with Joaquin/Russell against Cochran and I'd already heard she wasn't a fan of Penner, so she was seen as someone more in the middle. So really that only left you and Yve, and then Cassandra/Kim/Penner. Honestly if I were to solely pick the target at this point, I had more going with you than I did with Cassandra/Penner or even Yve at this point, but I do think NuMunin had an agreement and any talks of doing Cassandra/Penner weren't met with any assurance to where I'd sure the plan would actually work, and I didn't want to risk one of my pre-merge allies leaving.
There were other factors too, like speculation one of Cassandra/Kim/Penner
had to have the OG Fenrir idol (I guess that thing was never found, lol?), given we knew Russell's OG Munin idol lasted three rounds, and for Cassandra/Kim/Penner, the merge vote was their Tribal Council. Putting votes on them would be extremely risky and again, risking one of my pre-merge allies from leaving and I didn't want that, as what happened with Val was definitely a letdown and
that's exactly what I wanted to avoid. And not to mention Joaquin/Russell weren't putting up any resistance to put the hit on you and Yve despite just coming off the tribe with you.
So once the Val disaster happened and I lost someone I'd been with the entire game and trusted to have my back, honestly I was pretty annoyed the Munin group fucked up a simple plan when we had a clear majority, and made it no secret I wanted us to get our shit together the next time around and vote seven strong on a Fenrir to avoid a similar Val situation happening if people strayed. Based on you being the primary target the previous round, I think that was just an easy excuse to make you the target the next time around. I know that's not really fair and you didn't even do anything wrong, but there was just an urgency for a Fenrir to go at that point so the numbers didn't get tied up 6-6 after we had 8-6.
So I really am sorry that I wasn't able to uphold my end of the deal and give you protection from the Munin side of things, because I did see it as genuine on your part given we were connecting in a social sense before you pitched that, and not something you were just running around saying to all the Munin out of desperation. In a world where you were able to survive that round before the tribal lines dissolved I'd like to think we would've had more wiggle room to play together deeper into the merge, but it wasn't meant to be. I hope this sheds some light into my thought process those two rounds though and you can understand where I'm coming from and why it ultimately made sense for my game in terms of my path towards making it to the end here.
Also please do an impression of me in your response. Make it good because my vote may depend on it.
Eep, pressure's on!
"Well I may have narrowly beaten my pre-game prediction of getting 15th place so I'm counting that as a win and yolo I don't need $200 am i right????? I already won and some might agree 2014 was the best year to win Stranded anyway. Too bad I DIDNT end up in 15th place or else I would've been in the pre-jury with Penny like the good old days the first round of Fenrir and reunite with my one true love after she left me on READ when she PROMISED to talk game with me. Smh. Plus it would've been nice to get away from the rest of the jurors who avoided me the entire two rounds I was in the merge like I had COVID or something!!!"
Now it feels full circle! I hope that's a good enough impression to earn your vote just as my impressions of Courtney/Mookie/Spradlin were good enough to win you the challenge, right?!?!